Chrysler 300 SRT vs HSV Clubsport R8 LSA Tourer

Chrysler 300 SRT vs HSV Clubsport R8 LSA Tourer

America owes Australia. No, really, when you think about it, the US has a lot to thank its pals Down Under for.

Whenever it goes to war we’re there to help out, we ship our finest talent over – Cate Blanchett, Geoffrey Rush, Eric Bana, Hugh Jackman and more – to make its movies better and we’re happy to lend a hand on the car front, too.

The Monaro and latest VF Commodore made their way Stateside, as did the Caprice, which saved US police officers from enduring any more motoring misery from behind the wheel of ancient Ford Crown Victorias.

300 SRT vs Clubsport R8 rearSo without putting too fine a point on it, it’s time we got something in return – and no, X Factor judges don’t count. Fortunately, Chrysler has come to the rescue with the new 300 SRT. Available only in Australia and the Middle East, Chrysler has somehow managed to make a business case for a model that’s only shifted around 4000 units in the last decade.

But we’re glad it has, because when it comes to V8 rear-drive muscle cars, there’s no such thing as too much choice.

It’s not the only gift we can enjoy from Uncle Sam, however. As you’re probably aware by now, as part of its MY16 Gen-F2 update, HSV has installed the 6.2-litre supercharged LSA V8, originally found in the Camaro ZL-1 and Cadillac CTS-V models Stateside, under the bonnet of its Clubsport, Maloo and Senator models.

supercharged LSA V8 engineThis means that, depending on your taste, you can sample 400kW/671Nm of blown V8 in sedan, ute or wagon flavours.

Having driven the sedan last month and the Maloo on page 42, we chose the wagon for this comparison because, well, we wanted to; since when is an excuse needed to drive a 400kW station wagon?

Sadly, Chrysler no longer offers a wagon option for its 300 SRT. Buyers wanting Hemi-powered practicality can always stump up $84,000 for a Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT, however unless you really need the extra load space the Chrysler is the car to have, not least because you can enjoy the same 6.4-litre V8 for just $59,000.

Chrysler 300 SRT enginePacking 350kW/637Nm, the 300 SRT Core offers maximum kilowatts for your coin, however, if anything, our $69,000 300 SRT test car only strengthens the value equation.

Okay, so the interior doesn’t set any new benchmarks in material quality or fit and finish, but the amount of equipment contained within is just staggering.

Here is just a selection: heated and cooled front seats; heated rear seats; leather and alcantara upholstery; 19-speaker Harmon Kardon stereo; bi-Xenon headlights with adaptive cornering and auto high-beam functions; SRT Performance Pages with lap and acceleration timer; and a full suite of active safety gear, including blind-spot monitoring, adaptive cruise control, forward collision warning and lane departure warning.

SRT interiorIn fact, the combination of adaptive cruise control, which will bring the car to a complete halt and then resume with traffic without driver intervention, and lane keep assist, which subtly steers the car back to the centre of your lane should you drift over the white line, means the 300 SRT offers semi-autonomous driving.

The HSV can’t pull the same trick but offers similar levels of active safety tech, though most keen drivers will turn the systems off, their over-zealousness – emergency brake is particularly keen to activate for no reason – an irritation if you are actually paying attention.

While the Clubsport’s interior lacks the toys (heated and cooled seats) and tinsel (carbonfibre trim) of the Chrysler, it counters with a better driving position and head-up display, though it would be worth playing with trim colours to break up the overwhelming greyness of our test car.

HSV interiorThe Clubsport LSA range starts at$80,990 for a manual sedan, however the auto-only Tourer will set you back $85,990, making the 300 SRT look somewhat of a bargain. Then again, judged against its $10K pricier GTS sibling, this supercharged station wagon makes a strong case for itself, in a straight line at least.

It may be 30kW/69Nm down and weigh a portly 1974kg – a 67kg penalty over the Clubsport LSA sedan and 71kg more than the GTS – but the R8 LSA Tourer hits 100km/h in 4.54sec on its way to a 12.67sec quarter mile at 180.75km/h.

When it comes to bang for your buck, however, the Chrysler is king. At 1965kg it, too, is a heavy beast, yet it scorches to 100km/h in just 4.49sec and through 400m in 12.60sec at 180.54km/h, though if you believe the onboard computer it takes just 4.3sec and 12.3sec respectively, which illustrates the difference between DriftBox and drag strip timing.

Chrysler 300 SRT drivingIn pure performance terms you won’t find two more closely matched cars, but the way they deliver speed is very different. The long overdue installation of an eight-speed auto has transformed the Chrysler. The ’box itself is nothing special, particularly on downshifts, but the extra ratios make the engine feel so much more urgent, the giant Hemi eating up gear after gear with a vicious snarl.

In contrast, the Clubsport feels almost lazy in comparison, though lazy is the wrong adjective for a car that can accelerate so effortlessly and rapidly. The speed in each gear inexorably builds (and builds, and builds), the exhaust note hardening from a guttural growl – the kind you get from an angry dog warning you to not step any closer – to an enraged roar in the process.

Hsv clubsport tourer turningThe Clubby has a slightly hot-rod feel to it now, yet it is still extremely well-resolved – if anything, there’s the impression that it could easily handle even more power.

Traction is strong, even in the wet. In the dry it takes a fairly concerted effort to break the rear free, and when it does so it’s progressive and easily caught with a flick of opposite lock.

You could quite easily drive it without fear sans any electronic aids, though the Performance setting in the Driver Preference Dial is so good you might as well leave the safety net in place. The steering is weighty, perhaps slightly excessively so, and if we’re nit-picking it could be a bit quicker off-centre, but you can still place what is a very large car very accurately.

It feels to sit quite flat in corners; the LSA models’ stiffer spring and damper rates have largely eradicated the Commodore Redline’s off-throttle playfulness, but perhaps that’s no bad thing given the Tourer weighs well over two tonnes with a driver and a full tank of fuel on board.

300 SRT vs Clubsport R8 parkedThe Chrysler is equally bulky, and despite impressive hardware – both cars sport large discs and four-piston calipers front and rear – the brakes of each do feel the strain under continued heavy use.

In terms of cornering behaviour, the 300 SRT feels remarkably similar to its antipodean rival. Both cars are essentially neutral, with mid-corner understeer if you carry too much speed on entry and oversteer on exit if you use too much throttle.

The Chrysler’s ultimate limits are lower thanks to 245/45 R20 Goodyear Eagle F1 rubber all ’round versus the HSV’s 255/35 R20 (front) and 275/35 R20 (rear) Continentals, though the flip side of that is the harder Goodyears will cop more punishment than the sticky but soft Contis.

That said, it’s remarkable how good the big 300 is to drive hard. Looking at it you’d assume it’s going to handle with all the poise and finesse of a Melbourne tram, but while it’s never going to qualify for Swan Lake, it’s very capable and very friendly at the limit.

Chrysler 300 SRT turningInitially it feels a bit woolly, but delve into the SRT drive mode page and things improve markedly. With its three-stage adaptive dampers set to ‘Street’ the Chrysler is soft and wallowy, however Sport tightens up the body control without a huge deterioration in secondary ride quality (small, sharp impacts).

Likewise, the new electrically-assisted power steering is light and vague in Street, but Sport offers enough weight to lean against – if little in the way of actual feel. Track suspension and steering is probably a step too far for most people on the road, but the Track ESP setting is brilliant.

Lenient yet subtle in its interventions, if you need more slip angle than this on the street you’re going to end up on A Current Affair, though few cars are easier to drive extremely sideways if you have the venue and inclination to do so.

What ultimately costs the Chrysler, however, is its lack of composure at the limit. Up to around seven or eight-tenths it’s all pretty happy, but push harder and you start to wish for a bit more control and feedback.

Some issues are ergonomic; you sit high in the driver’s seat, the paddle shifters are awkwardly placed and the throttle action is incredibly long. But the main problem is that the 300 SRT always feels like an extremely big car, never shrinking around you in the same manner as the Clubsport.

300 SRT vs Clubsport R8But it does have other virtues. Any discussion of styling is always largely down to personal taste, but the Chrysler has a massive amount of presence. It’s brash and ostentatious – an automotive Kanye West – and, like the controversial rapper, guaranteed to cause a stir wherever you go. Just beware that the responses will range from adulation to revulsion.

On the other hand, it doesn’t get much more sensible than a Commodore wagon, though few will mistake the Clubsport R8 LSA Tourer for your run-of-the-mill Holden, especially once it starts up with a thunderous boom.

We reckon it looks awesome, understated yet aggressive, especially in HSV’s new Slipstream blue. And the new tail-lights, bonnet vents and sculpted side skirts freshen up its styling.

Between this, AMG’s C63 S Estate and CLA45 Shooting Brake, Audi’s RS6 and VW’s Golf R Wagon, we’re in a golden age of practical performance cars, which makes you wonder why anyone would want to buy an SUV. No sportified off-roader drives as well as the Clubsport, and it’s this dynamic prowess that gives the HSV the win here.

300 SRT vs Clubsport R8 LSA frontBut only by the slimmest of margins. The Chrysler is a surprise packet – it feels a bit like a cut-price E63 AMG, and that’s a good thing. It’s not the sharpest tool in the dynamic shed, but it sounds awesome, goes hard, is loaded with kit and is a whopping $17,000 cheaper than the HSV.

Not everyone is going to be a fan of the bling, but for those who are – people who wish their lives were more like The Sopranos, presumably – it’s a fine alternative to the traditional muscle car choices. We’re not square yet, America, but this is a good start.

    HSV CLUBSPORT R8 LSA TOURER   CHRYSLER 300 SRT
Body   5-door, 5-seat wagon   4-door, 5-seat sedan
Drive   rear-wheel   rear-wheel
Engine   6162cc V8, OHV, 16v, supercharger   6417c V8, OHV, 16v
Bore/Stroke   103.25 x 92.0mm   103.9 x 94.5mm
Compression   9.0:1   10.9:1
Power   400kW @ 6150rpm   350kW @ 6150rpm
Torque   671Nm @ 4200rpm   637Nm @ 4250rpm
Power/Weight   203kW/tonne   178kW/tonne
Transmission   6-speed automatic   8-speed automatic
Weight   1974kg   1965kg
Suspension (f)   struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar   double A-arms, coil springs, adaptive dampers, anti-roll bar
Suspension(r)   multi-links, coil springs, anti-roll bar   multi-links, coil springs, adaptive dampers, anti-roll bar
L/W/H   4978/1899/1454mm   5089/1902/1478mm
Wheelbase   2915mm   3052mm
Tracks   1616/1590mm (f/r)   1621/1639mm (f/r)
Steering   electrically-assisted rack-and-pinion   electrically-assisted rack-and-pinion
Brakes(f)   367mm ventilated discs, 4-piston calipers   360mm ventilated discs, 4-piston calipers
Brakes(r)   372mm solid discs, 4-piston calipers   350mm ventilated discs, 4-piston calipers
Wheels   20.0 x 8.5-inch (f); 20.0 x 9.5-inch (r)   20.0 x 9.0-inch (f/r)
Tyre Sizes   255/35 ZR20 (f); 275/35 ZR20 (r)   245/45 ZR20 (f/r) 
Tyre Sizes   Continental ContiSportContact5P   Goodyear Eagle F1
Price as tested   $85,990   $69,000
Pros   Supercharged grunt; polished dynamics   Searing pace; value; looks; ride comfort
Cons   Weight; firm ride; outrageous thirst   Steering better but not great; gearbox could be sharper

 

 

Get your free weekly report from the world of fast cars - subscribe to the MOTOR newsletter!